When cooking game meats, one needs to be attentive. Either undercooked or overcooked, it can be tough. There is a fine line, a narrow margin for error. My method for cooking elk medallions works perfectly: sear them well and finish in a relatively slow oven while you make the sauce.
When preparing most game, I lean towards an autumnal pairing, as I’ve previously done with these Elk Medallions with Wild Mushrooms. But I also really like using berries and other fruits to complement the flavor of the meat. Today, I made an elderberry sauce by deglazing the pan with butter, elderberry jelly, and a bit of red wine. Using jelly allows you to make this at any time of the year. It’s a simple and elegant dish, and I hope you will enjoy it.
Season the medallions liberally with salt, pepper, and ground bay leaves. Let sit at room temperature for 10-15 minutes.
Set a 10-inch skillet over medium-high heat; when hot, add 1 1/2 tablespoons of the butter and swirl the pan. Add the medallions and sear on the top and bottom until nicely browned—about 2 minutes per side. Using tongs, sear the edges until a little browned. Return the medallions to either their top or bottom and place in the oven for 5-6 minutes, or until done to your liking. Remove from the oven and transfer medallions to a warmed plate; tent to keep warm as they rest.
Return the skillet to the stovetop (medium-high) and add remaining butter and the jelly. When the jelly is melted, deglaze the pan with the red wine. Cook until syrupy, adding more wine if necessary.
Slice the medallions and fan out each medallion on dinner plates. Spoon elderberry sauce over, add vegetables, and serve.
Your technique for cooking elk would also be good for cooking a simple steak. Nice plating plus the purple cauliflower looks interesting. BTW, I like your blog because the format is simple; it doesn’t include a lot of sub-sections, like “What you’ll love about this dish” or “How long will this dish last in the fridge”, etc.
You made my day, Fran. When I redesigned the blog, I tried for simple — often two paragraphs, but little text. People come for the recipes.. and a little for the stories. But, since I don’t/won’t do ads, there is no need to string the reader along unnecessarily!
Yes, this method works well for steak, pork medallions, or venison. Super simple and yet elegant.
I have not used or had elk, but definitely something I want to try. And for me, I want my steak very very very very rare and really bloody..even my cats love raw meat..threw them a piece of raw liver, it’s gone in a nano second, a medium rare liver, they walked away…
I like simple, beautiful meals like this one! I’ve never had elk but I cook venison medallions using the sear and finish in the oven technique. It works perfectly every time. The elderberry sauce sounds perfect to accompany the meat. I made the elk and mushroom recipe using venison and it was fabulous!
I think my favorite thing about the oven time is that it gives you a few minutes to prep everything else for the plating! Hands-off time is so valuable! Glad you liked the mushroom version (with mushroom umami, I hope) — I think you will like this one, too.
David yours looks like such a delicious plate of food. Love the purple veg, and I’m now on the hunt for elderberry jelly. As you say always handy to have jellies in the pantry. Best wishes, Pauline (Happy Retirees Kitchen)
There is wildlife in all of Thailand’s national parks. Among the “wild” animals found there are the muntjac, the sambar, and the barking deer.
They’re not usually served on a plate here.
Still, your recipe really makes my mouth watering – especially the elderberry sauce!
I have never tried elk, but I will try it if I get the chance. If they carry it around here, I’m sure it’s frozen. 🙂 The perfectly cooked medium rare meat with this sauce looks like wonderful comfort food, David. I may try to make a plum sauce with plum jelly for pork chops some time this fall. Thank you for sharing how to make the sauce with jelly!
There couldn’t be a more beautiful plate! It’s stunning – so vibrant and colorful, and each item is mouth-watering. I haven’t cooked with elk before, but this technique sounds perfect for it, and for other meats as well. 🙂 ~Valentina
Beautiful plate! I’m yet to try elk meat, but when I’ll get to it, I’ll definitely try your method, as the meat looks perfectly cooked and succulent. Love such simple, yet complex, sauces. 🙂
Fabulous! What an elegant dish, David – and that elk looks beautifiully cooked. I also love what you’ve plated it with. This would be an amazing Christmas dinner.
We recently ate at Indígena by Owamni in Minneapolis and they had berry sauces with a number of dishes. I was surprised (and delighted) to learn the surprising pairing berries can be with so many dishes. Love the colors in your plating!
That elderberry sauce sounds like a brilliant pairing for elk, especially with the richness of the seared meat balanced by the fruity sweetness and acidity of the red wine.
Fran @ G'day Souffle'
October 31, 2026 at 4:34 amYour technique for cooking elk would also be good for cooking a simple steak. Nice plating plus the purple cauliflower looks interesting. BTW, I like your blog because the format is simple; it doesn’t include a lot of sub-sections, like “What you’ll love about this dish” or “How long will this dish last in the fridge”, etc.
David Scott Allen
October 31, 2026 at 9:21 amYou made my day, Fran. When I redesigned the blog, I tried for simple — often two paragraphs, but little text. People come for the recipes.. and a little for the stories. But, since I don’t/won’t do ads, there is no need to string the reader along unnecessarily!
Yes, this method works well for steak, pork medallions, or venison. Super simple and yet elegant.
Mad Dog
October 31, 2026 at 4:42 amThat looks fabulous – I love venison, so I’m sure your elk is delicious!
David Scott Allen
October 31, 2026 at 9:18 amThanks, Mad Dog — I am pretty sure you would like elk — very similar to venison.
Mimi Rippee
October 31, 2026 at 6:31 amDelicious! I’ve only used elk once and it turned out perfectly. Glad I didn’t know abut that fine line! A beautiful plate of food, David!
David Scott Allen
October 31, 2026 at 9:18 amThanks, Mimi! I am not surprised yours turned out well!
angiesrecipes
October 31, 2026 at 6:45 amI have not used or had elk, but definitely something I want to try. And for me, I want my steak very very very very rare and really bloody..even my cats love raw meat..threw them a piece of raw liver, it’s gone in a nano second, a medium rare liver, they walked away…
David Scott Allen
October 31, 2026 at 9:17 amI pretty much know you will love this, Angie. Thanks!
Barb
October 31, 2026 at 7:06 amI like simple, beautiful meals like this one! I’ve never had elk but I cook venison medallions using the sear and finish in the oven technique. It works perfectly every time. The elderberry sauce sounds perfect to accompany the meat. I made the elk and mushroom recipe using venison and it was fabulous!
David Scott Allen
October 31, 2026 at 9:17 amI think my favorite thing about the oven time is that it gives you a few minutes to prep everything else for the plating! Hands-off time is so valuable! Glad you liked the mushroom version (with mushroom umami, I hope) — I think you will like this one, too.
Pauline
October 31, 2026 at 3:11 pmDavid yours looks like such a delicious plate of food. Love the purple veg, and I’m now on the hunt for elderberry jelly. As you say always handy to have jellies in the pantry. Best wishes, Pauline (Happy Retirees Kitchen)
David Scott Allen
October 31, 2026 at 3:15 pmThanks, Pauline. I think there are many jellies that would work, but elderberry is quite wonderful. I am not sure if you even have them in Australia?
FEL!X
October 31, 2026 at 10:10 pmThere is wildlife in all of Thailand’s national parks. Among the “wild” animals found there are the muntjac, the sambar, and the barking deer.
They’re not usually served on a plate here.
Still, your recipe really makes my mouth watering – especially the elderberry sauce!
Marcelle
October 31, 2026 at 10:20 pmI have never tried elk, but I will try it if I get the chance. If they carry it around here, I’m sure it’s frozen. 🙂 The perfectly cooked medium rare meat with this sauce looks like wonderful comfort food, David. I may try to make a plum sauce with plum jelly for pork chops some time this fall. Thank you for sharing how to make the sauce with jelly!
Valentina
November 1, 2026 at 1:56 pmThere couldn’t be a more beautiful plate! It’s stunning – so vibrant and colorful, and each item is mouth-watering. I haven’t cooked with elk before, but this technique sounds perfect for it, and for other meats as well. 🙂 ~Valentina
Ronit
November 1, 2026 at 3:39 pmBeautiful plate! I’m yet to try elk meat, but when I’ll get to it, I’ll definitely try your method, as the meat looks perfectly cooked and succulent. Love such simple, yet complex, sauces. 🙂
Jeff the Chef
November 2, 2026 at 7:32 pmFabulous! What an elegant dish, David – and that elk looks beautifiully cooked. I also love what you’ve plated it with. This would be an amazing Christmas dinner.
Frank | Memorie di Angelina
November 3, 2026 at 7:28 amSimple, elegant and done to absolute perfection! I do enjoy game meats in general, but I’ve never had elk.. Does it taste as “beefy” as it looks?
2pots2cook
November 4, 2026 at 2:54 amWhenever we travel to Nordic countries, we have their typical meals and I find elk of too intense flavours. Would it be all right to use beef instead?
Sherry M
November 4, 2026 at 5:43 pmNo elk here but there’s always kangaroo 🦘!
Sherry
Inger
November 9, 2026 at 8:27 pmWe recently ate at Indígena by Owamni in Minneapolis and they had berry sauces with a number of dishes. I was surprised (and delighted) to learn the surprising pairing berries can be with so many dishes. Love the colors in your plating!
Raymund
November 12, 2026 at 3:14 pmThat elderberry sauce sounds like a brilliant pairing for elk, especially with the richness of the seared meat balanced by the fruity sweetness and acidity of the red wine.